Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Performance Commentaries: 2008/02/15 超級星光大道第三季 Part 01 to Part 05

As per my usual practice, I like to blog and comment on performances. This, of course, doesn't mean I am hammering the contestants/performers as if I am better than them. I am just sharing my opinions on how they have done or what else they could have improved on.

This will be a series of commentary blog posts as the abovementioned competition progresses. Whenever I can spare the time to look through the Youtube videos and comment, I would put up more of these commentaries up so do stay tuned if you are interested to read what I have to say.



《寫一首歌》是首非常难演绎的歌曲,歌词多,拍子节奏变化多,感觉要对,林雨嫻唱得还不错,可是柔弱了点,带不足那份的感觉,不 过勇气可嘉!



我很喜欢赖珍珍的外形和笑容,因为这两点她确实占了优势,可是也很明显的,她的咬字和呼吸,技巧不够好,输了。希望她能多下点功 夫,因为有可塑性。

徐佳瑩 - 好个自弹自唱,加分因为有吉他所以难度倍增。她在主歌部份显得比较不自然,有点木纳,可是到了复歌就比较轻松,唱得也入歌了。外 形虽处下风,可是还有个性可以做卖点。





賞盈希好深厚的舞蹈底子,能够有这么多动作伴唱,可是我认为她的舞台动作太多,无法专心看她演绎歌曲的神情,是跳过头了。她得好 好恢复嗓子,不然肯定无法再普极了。

李宏武的声线很纯很美,听了很舒服,可是他的脸部表情却很糟糕,很木板的神情,左手的动作也是一样乏味。台上表演也得注意视觉的 美感呀!




王威登的声线确实很像张学友,厚厚的,很耐听,可是他的舞台动作有点硬,跟柔合的歌曲有点出入。我是听到了他的p- and b- 字发音吐字太用力,得稍微修饰下。

商織樺的唱法很独特,我唯一能拿来比较的应该是 The Corrs. 她唱得蛮有韵味,可是总是把眼睛合起来,放弃了与观众和镜头眼神交流的机会,就有点自唱自爽的诠释了。


鐘雨帆的尾音,尾字都没有唱齐,咬清,所以我是先期望后失望,因为她每句的前部处理得蛮有感觉和特色,没一味跟随原唱的方法。有 点可惜因为她可能唱得更好的,加油!

No comments: